AGRO-FORESTRY

Exploring Market-Oriented Agroforestry for Sustainable Farming in India

Written by Anshu Pandit (Masters Student at APU)

Agroforestry is a symphony of nature’s finest elements that promise to harmonize the needs of farmers and the heartbeat of our planet. It is considered as an avant-garde solution to the dual challenge of enhancing profitability for farmers while ensuring long-term ecological sustainability. It is a dynamic, ecologically based, natural resource management system that introduces trees into farmland and rangeland, diversifying and sustaining smallholder production, ultimately leading to social, economic, and environmental benefits1. A pivotal strategy in this endeavour is aligning agroforestry with market-oriented approaches, where sustainability converges with profitability.

History of Agroforestry in India

Agroforestry isn’t a new concept; it has deep historical roots dating back thousands of years. Traditional agroforestry practices were integral to numerous cultures and civilizations worldwide notably in India. In Northern India, the practice is referred to as “Kheti-Wadi,” while the southern region is renowned for its forest gardens in Kerala2. Traditional agroforestry systems evolved organically, driven by societies seeking ways to optimize land utilization while maintaining harmony with the environment. These traditional systems demonstrated remarkable diversity and effectiveness by interweaving fruit trees, nut-bearing trees, and medicinal plants with staple crops.

Embracing agroforestry on a broader scale in India holds the potential to meet the needs of a growing population while paving the way for a sustainable future. At present agroforestry meets almost half of the demand for fuelwood, two-thirds of the small timber, 70–80% of wood for plywood, 60% of raw material for paper pulp and 9–11% of the green fodder requirement of livestock (NRCAF 2013) It is a strategy to offset greenhouse gas emissions and could help achieve India’s Nationally Determined Contributions to the United Nations Framework

Convention on Climate Change.3 The Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) recognizes the necessity for a substantial increase in food production to cater to the expanding global population, projected to reach 9.3 billion by 2050. Within this context, agroforestry is identified as a sustainable agricultural practice with the capacity to enhance food productions. However, the picture of agroforestry is not so rosy. Issues like delayed return to investment, underdeveloped and inefficient markets for tree products in contrast to crop and livestock commodities, monoculture systems offering incentives for commercial agriculture while neglecting trees, and lack of coordination among several departments like agriculture and forest create policy conflicts and gaps that hinder agroforestry’s development.

Transition to Market-Driven Agroforestry

In recent decades, agroforestry has transitioned from subsistence-based practices to market-driven strategies. Several factors have fueled this shift including Indian agriculture’s situation facing growing demographic pressure, increasing needs for food, feed, pulp, fodder and timber, degradation of natural resources and climate change. Nearly 120.72 million ha of land or 37 per cent of the total geographical area is under one or the other forms of soil degradation which can be brought under cultivation through agroforestry. It is believed that establishing agroforestry on land that currently has low tree cover has been identified as one of the most promising strategies to raise food production without additional deforestation(Garrity et al., 2010)4. All these factors along with the recent technological advancement in the production of high-value tree products alongside traditional crops and globalization expanding the markets for tree products have driven the demand towards this transition.

Core Principles of Agroforestry

Agroforestry operates based on a set of core principles that involve competition, complexity, profitability and sustainability5. Competition and complexity are central aspects of agroforestry systems. These systems involve interactions among plants, which can be either complementary or competitive, impacting crucial resources like light, water, and nutrients. Initially, the assumption was that trees and crops complemented each other in agroforestry. However, competition exists. Agroforestry systems are broadly categorized as simultaneous, (where trees and crops grow together), and sequential, (where their growth peaks at different times).

Profitability and sustainability are two other pivotal aspects of agroforestry. Economically, agroforestry diversifies farmers’ income streams through valuable tree products, livestock integration, and carbon credits. This diversification reduces vulnerability to market fluctuations, thereby enhancing financial resilience. Simultaneously, agroforestry optimizes land productivity by strategically aligning tree and crop growth patterns, improving soil health, and safeguarding crops from environmental stress. This leads to achieving more with less land and reduces input costs, promoting cost-effectiveness. In terms of sustainability, agroforestry fosters biodiversity, conserves soil and water, and sequesters carbon, safeguarding the environment. It improves livelihoods, preserves indigenous knowledge, and enhances community resilience socio-culturally, making it a holistic approach to agriculture with positive economic and ecological outcomes.

India’s Role in Promoting Agroforestry

Since India is endowed with a variety of agroclimatic conditions, there is a significant variation in agroforestry systems’ structural complexity and species diversity, as well as in their protective and productive characteristics and socioeconomic aspects. They range from seemingly simple forms of shifting cultivation to complex home gardens: from systems involving sparse stands of trees on farmlands (like Prosopis cineraria in arid regions of Rajasthan) to high-density complex multi-story homesteads of Kerala. from systems in which trees primarily serve as a “service”(such as shelter belts) to those in which they produce the majority of the marketable goods (such as intercropping with plantation crops)4.

Map showing the major agroforestry types and farming systems of India. Map courtesy of Arun Jyoti Nath, modified version of Nath et al. 2020.6

India plays a pivotal role in the promotion and advancement of agroforestry, a sustainable land-use system that integrates trees with crops and livestock. This role is exemplified by India’s comprehensive policy framework, including the National Agroforestry Policy (NAP) introduced in 2014, which provides guidelines and incentives for agroforestry adoption. Government initiatives like the Sub-Mission on Agroforestry (SMAF) and provisions within the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) further support agroforestry efforts. India’s vibrant research community, led by institutions like the Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR), conducts crucial research to develop tailored agroforestry systems and practices. International collaborations with organizations like the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) and practical demonstrations of successful agroforestry projects underscore India’s commitment to this sustainable land-use approach, which also contributes to climate change mitigation and agricultural resilience.

Case Studies from India

India has showcased several agroforestry case studies and demonstration projects, highlighting the manifold economic, environmental, and social benefits of these practices. Notably, the “Chhattisgarh Agroforestry Development Project” aimed to uplift the livelihoods of smallholder farmers in the Chhattisgarh region by promoting agroforestry methods like alley cropping and silvopasture. This initiative not only bolstered farmers’ incomes but also contributed to enhanced soil fertility and carbon sequestration. Additionally, in Karnataka, the integration of chikoo (sapodilla) and teak trees into agricultural systems has proven fruitful. Chikoo provides regular income through fruit sales, while teak serves as a valuable timber source, exemplifying the symbiotic relationship between short-term and long-term tree crops. Moreover, in Kerala’s highlands, multi-layered agroforestry systems incorporating coffee, cardamom, pepper, and fruit trees have emerged as highly profitable models, characterized by diverse income streams and efficient land utilization, thus underlining their sustainability and economic viability..

An illustrative case involves Ramabhimappa, a farmer residing in Anantapur district of Andhra Pradesh. With the assistance of the Saytrees organization, he implemented a 3-acre agroforestry model on his land. In this model, Ramabhimappa cultivates mango, guava, and jamun trees alongside a diverse range of crops, including methi and palak. This multi-layered approach not only provides a continuous income stream but also ensures that various crops mature and yield fruits at different times.

Challenges and Solutions

Agroforestry, particularly when oriented towards the market, faces a spectrum of challenges spanning economic, environmental, social, and policy domains. Economically, there are barriers linked to substantial initial investments in tree planting and maintenance, potentially limiting access for smallholder farmers. The reliance on tree products can also render farmers susceptible to market fluctuations and price volatility, necessitating improved access to financial resources and credit. Environmentally, striking a balance between agroforestry’s economic objectives and ecological preservation can prove complex; aggressive tree planting may disrupt natural ecosystems and lead to biodiversity loss, mandating careful land-use planning and ecological assessments to ensure long-term sustainability. Socially, resistance to change can impede agroforestry adoption, as farmers may be hesitant to shift from traditional agricultural practices, and land tenure issues can arise due to unclear property rights. To address these social challenges, education, awareness campaigns, and land tenure reforms are indispensable. Lastly, policy inconsistencies or inadequacies can impede market-oriented agroforestry, stemming from unclear land-use regulations, a lack of incentives for farmers, and limited market access for agroforestry products. To overcome these policy challenges, comprehensive frameworks that not only promote agroforestry but also provide essential support measures are imperative.

Scalability Potential

The market structure of agroforestry encompasses the entire supply chain and economic relationships linked to agroforestry products. To enhance the scalability of agroforestry, numerous factors within this market structure merit consideration. Firstly, the vast array of agroforestry products, from timber to fruits and non-timber forest products (NTFPs), presents marketing challenges alongside niche market opportunities. Local markets serve as starting points, with farmers’ markets, community-supported agriculture (CSA) programs, and direct consumer sales playing pivotal roles in small-scale agroforestry endeavours. Adding value through processing and packaging enhances product marketability, while certifications like organic or Fair Trade can open doors to premium markets. Cooperatives and producer groups can benefit small-scale producers by reducing marketing costs and improving negotiation positions. Access to credit and financing options proves vital for scaling up agroforestry operations, and supportive government policies, such as incentives and regulations, foster sustainable practices. Market research, extension services, partnerships, sustainable practices, consumer education, export opportunities, and climate finance mechanisms like carbon credits all contribute to the expansion and sustainability of agroforestry. Addressing these factors, adapting strategies to local contexts, and fostering an enabling environment is key to realizing the scalability potential of agroforestry.

The Path Forward

In considering the prospects and recommendations for market-oriented agroforestry, several key avenues for development emerge. Embracing cutting-edge technology and innovation, including tools like drones for tree monitoring and genetic engineering for improved tree varieties, can amplify agroforestry practices. Moreover, investing in region-specific research models and robust extension services is pivotal

in disseminating knowledge and skills among farmers, encompassing agroforestry best practices, market insights, and financial literacy. The synergy of public-private partnerships can establish vital market linkages for agroforestry products, stimulating economic growth and empowering smallholder farmers. In terms of policy recommendations, governments should incentivize agroforestry adoption through financial incentives, tax breaks, and subsidies while simultaneously embarking on land tenure reforms to clarify property rights for long-term agroforestry projects. Facilitating market access by reducing trade barriers and implementing equitable pricing mechanisms for agroforestry products is equally important.

In conclusion, market-oriented agroforestry, as underscored by its capacity to diversify income streams, bolster land productivity, and promote environmental conservation, is poised as a dynamic solution in modern agriculture. The nexus between profitability and sustainability, exemplified by success stories and best practices, highlights its tangible benefits. The path forward entails leveraging technology, enhancing knowledge dissemination, nurturing partnerships, and prioritizing sustainability to pave the way for a prosperous and ecologically sound agricultural future.

REFERENCES

1. Leakey, R. R. B. (2017a). Definition of agroforestry revisited. In R. R. B. Leakey (Ed.), Multifunctional Agriculture — Achieving Sustainable Development in Africa (pp. 5–6). Academic Press.file:///C:/Users/APU/Downloads/Definition%20of%20Agroforestry%20Revisited%20(1). pdf
2. Lovett, T. (2021). Challenges to scaling agroforestry in India. 4 Returns Towards Healthy Landscapes.https://4returns.commonland.com/stories/challenges-to-scaling-agroforestry-in-india/
3. Nath, A. J., Sileshi, G. W., Laskar, S. Y., Pathak, K., Reang, D., Nath, A., & Das, A. K. (2021). Quantifying carbon stocks and sequestration potential in agroforestry systems under divergent management scenarios relevant to India’s Nationally Determined Contribution. Journal of Cleaner Production, 281, 124831.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.124831
4. Prasad, R., Dhyani, S. K., Newaj, R., & Tripathi, V. D. (2019). Contribution of advanced agroforestry research in sustaining soil quality for increased food production and food security. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 15(1), 31–39.
5. Sanchez, E. A. (1995). Science in agroforestry. Agroforestry Systems, 30(1), 5–55. https://sci-hub.se/https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00708912
6. Jain, N. (2021, July 6). Harnessing the unrealized potential of agroforestry in curbing climate change in India. Mongabay: News and Inspiration from Nature’s Frontline in Ind
7. Mastroianni, K., Adser, L. S., Loibl, S., Eitrem, G., Fogd, M., & Agroforestry Network. (2020). AGROFORESTRY VALUE CHAINS AND MARKET SYSTEMS — 2020.https://agroforestrynetwork.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/Agroforestry-Value-Chains and-Market-Systems.pdf
8. Jitendra. (2023). India becomes the first country to adopt an agroforestry policy. Down To Earth.https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/india-becomes-first-country-to-adopt-an-agroforest ry-policy-43518
9. Toppo, P., Raj, A., Jhariya, M. K. (2016). Agroforestry systems practiced in Dhamtari district of Chhattisgarh, India. Journal of Applied and Natural Science, 8(4), 1850–1854. DOI: 10.31018/jans.v8i4.1052 https://www.researchgate.net/publication/311587499_Agroforestry_systems_practiced_in _Dhamtari_district_of_Chhattisgarh_India/citations
10. Handa, A. K., Dev, I., Rizvi, R. H., Kumar, N., Ram, A., Kumar, D., Kumar, A., Bhaskar, S., Dhyani, S. K., & Rizvi, J. (Eds.). (2019). Successful Agroforestry Models for Different Agro-Ecological Regions in India. Central Agroforestry Research Institute (CAFRI) & World Agroforestry (ICRAF).https://apps.worldagroforestry.org/downloads/Publications/PDFS/B17980.pdf
11. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/Plainspeak/growing-money-on-trees-agroforest ry-can-spark-a-new-economic-revolution-for-india/
12. Dhyani, S. K., Ram, A., & Dev, I. (2016). Potential of agroforestry systems in carbon sequestration in India. Indian Journal of Agricultural Sciences, 86(9), 1103–1112.
13. https://www.fao.org/forestry/agroforestry/90001/en/
14. Sarveswaran, S., Johar, V., Singh, D. V., & Ragunanthan, C. (2023). Agroforestry: A Way Forward for Sustainable Development. Ecology Environment and Conservation, 29(Suppl), 300–309. doi: 10.53550/EEC.2023.v29i04s.046